Econ
Mobifone to be prosecuted over AVG acquisition
Mobifone`s acquisition of 95% of multimedia company Audio Visual Global (AVG) is a serious economic violation, according to the Government Inspectorate (GI)`s inspection results on the case released on March 14.
Following the results, GI recommended the Ministry of Public Security to take over the investigation and prosecute violators in accordance with the law.
GI's inspection found that Mobifone was irresponsible and violated a series of regulations during the acquisition of AVG. Problems were uncovered especially in the assessment of AVG's financial situation, leading to a potential loss of VND7 trillion (US$307 million) to the state budget.
Specifically, since its establishment to March 2015 (the date of its valuation), AVG had been struggling to stay profitable and reported an accumulated loss of VND1.6 trillion (US$70.2 million), or 45% of its charter capital.
Mobifone, however, reported inaccurately on the financial situation of AVG to the Ministry of Information and Communications (MIC), the representative of the state capital in Mobifone. According to GI, the telco assessed the business and financial situation of AVG to be positive.
Mobifone is also to blame for its decision of choosing business valuation consultants, examining the business valuation's results, and using those results as the basis for buying AVG's shares.
The performance of these consultants, as GI concluded, was biased and lacked credibility, violating the government's regulations on business valuation.
In conclusion, GI stated that responsibility for the wrongdoings lied at the Board of Members, Board of Directors, and other relevant departments of Mobifone, along with other related ministries, which have given opinion and approval for the acquisition.
In a surprise move, Mobifone and AVG have previously agreed to cancel the acquisition deal on March 12, two days before GI announced its inspection results.
Under the agreement, AVG will refund the entire contracted amount, which is reportedly VND8.9 trillion (US$392 million), to Mobifone including interest.
Mobifone, in turn, will return the shares purchased along with AVG's assets included in the original deal.
Concurrently, the two parties are trying to minimize potential financial hits from the decision.
Pham Nhat Vu, AVG's representative at the meeting, has agreed not to exercise the penalty clauses and request compensation after the deal was revoked. In addition to the refunded contract value, AVG will reimburse Mobifone for any expense during the transaction process.
The deal caused great controversy as its value was 2.58 times higher than AVG's charter capital of VND3.6 trillion (US$158 million) at the time of completing the transaction on January 2, 2016.
The investment in AVG was equivalent to 55% of Mobifone's charter capital (VND16.2 trillion or US$711 million) and 40% of its total assets (VND23.2 trillion or US$1.02 billion) as of June 30, 2016.
On September 6, 2016 the Government Inspectorate announced their decision to investigate Mobifone over the deal. The investigation was to last for 50 days, however, the process has been dragged out to over one and a half years since then.
Mobifone was irresponsible and violated a series of regulations during the acquisition of AVG.
|
Specifically, since its establishment to March 2015 (the date of its valuation), AVG had been struggling to stay profitable and reported an accumulated loss of VND1.6 trillion (US$70.2 million), or 45% of its charter capital.
Mobifone, however, reported inaccurately on the financial situation of AVG to the Ministry of Information and Communications (MIC), the representative of the state capital in Mobifone. According to GI, the telco assessed the business and financial situation of AVG to be positive.
Mobifone is also to blame for its decision of choosing business valuation consultants, examining the business valuation's results, and using those results as the basis for buying AVG's shares.
The performance of these consultants, as GI concluded, was biased and lacked credibility, violating the government's regulations on business valuation.
In conclusion, GI stated that responsibility for the wrongdoings lied at the Board of Members, Board of Directors, and other relevant departments of Mobifone, along with other related ministries, which have given opinion and approval for the acquisition.
In a surprise move, Mobifone and AVG have previously agreed to cancel the acquisition deal on March 12, two days before GI announced its inspection results.
Under the agreement, AVG will refund the entire contracted amount, which is reportedly VND8.9 trillion (US$392 million), to Mobifone including interest.
Mobifone, in turn, will return the shares purchased along with AVG's assets included in the original deal.
Concurrently, the two parties are trying to minimize potential financial hits from the decision.
Pham Nhat Vu, AVG's representative at the meeting, has agreed not to exercise the penalty clauses and request compensation after the deal was revoked. In addition to the refunded contract value, AVG will reimburse Mobifone for any expense during the transaction process.
The deal caused great controversy as its value was 2.58 times higher than AVG's charter capital of VND3.6 trillion (US$158 million) at the time of completing the transaction on January 2, 2016.
The investment in AVG was equivalent to 55% of Mobifone's charter capital (VND16.2 trillion or US$711 million) and 40% of its total assets (VND23.2 trillion or US$1.02 billion) as of June 30, 2016.
On September 6, 2016 the Government Inspectorate announced their decision to investigate Mobifone over the deal. The investigation was to last for 50 days, however, the process has been dragged out to over one and a half years since then.
